Scalia’s View on Gay Marriage Seeps Out in Vehement DOMA Dissent
In light of the recent decision by the Supreme Court of the United States to overturn the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), many have spoken out against the verdict, none more stridently than Justice Antonin Scalia. Scalia attacked Justice Kennedy’s majority opinion on several fronts, arguing that in repealing the bill the court had effectively labeled DOMA supporters “enemies of the human race.” The gist of Scalia’s argument, and a central passage from his dissent states that “to defend traditional marriage is not to condemn, demean, or humiliate those who would prefer other arrangements, any more than to defend the constitution of the United States is to condemn, demean, or humiliate other constitutions.” What Scalia attempts to convey through this argument is that DOMA was not an attack on gay people, but simply a cementation of “traditional marriage” and that the two are far from synonymous.
However, in the window where these strands of thought differ lies the primary justification for the Supreme Court’s decision. What Scalia’s “condemn, demean and humiliate” analogy fails to recognize (among other issues) is that upholding DOMA given the opportunity to overturn it would have rendered the act a tacit attack on gay rights.
This is apparent if we consider, say, interracial marriage. Though an act defining marriage as “the union between a white man and a white woman, or a black man and a black woman,” may not be intended, as Scalia suggests, to “condemn, demean and humiliate” black or white people, but merely to uphold “traditional marriage,” it would, nevertheless, attack equal rights. Scalia’s statement that “[DOMA] did no more than codify an aspect of marriage that had been unquestioned in our society for most of its existence — indeed, had been unquestioned in virtually all societies for virtually all of human history” could have just as easily have been the basis for the prohibition against interracial marriage. Indeed, the trial judge in the miscegenation case, Loving v. Commonwealth of Virginia, found justification for convicting the Lovings’ of breaking that law in the belief that “almighty God created the races white, black, yellow, malay and red, and he placed them on separate continents. And but for the interference with his arrangement there would be no cause for such marriages. The fact that he separated the races shows that he did not intend for the races to mix.”
While Scalia’s point may be historically correct, it is in no way a justification for upholding DOMA. Indeed, even if DOMA’s sole purpose was to remain true to history, its effect was to deprive gay couples of rights and privileges enjoyed by other legally married couples for no other reason than that they are gay. Rejecting the opportunity to repeal the act would unequivocally have been an attack (though perhaps an indirect one) on gay rights.
Though Scalia has frequently ruled in opposition to gay rights, in his dissent he made few outright objections to the idea of same-sex marriage, choosing instead to attack the power of the court (or lack thereof), in ruling on DOMA to begin with. Scalia relied on the idea that the court should have “[promised] all sides of this debate that it was theirs to settle,” lamenting the fact that the court had “cheated both sides.”
Regardless of the legitimacy or illegitimacy of Scalia’s denigration of the court for its assumed role in DOMA’s overturning (“an assertion,” Scalia writes, that “envisions the Supreme Court standing [or rather enthroned] at the apex of government”), it is Scalia’s suggestion that historical precedent may justify current inequality that renders his opinion misguided.
Get Top Stories Delivered Weekly
Discuss This Article
More Uloop Politics Articles
Recent Ohio State News Articles
RECENT OHIO STATE CLASSIFIEDS
GET TOP STORIES DELIVERED WEEKLY
TOP OHIO STATE NEWS
- 5 Issues You May Run Into On Move-In Day
- Are You A Smoker? You're Making $10K Less A Year
- Atom Tickets Helps Bring "Nerve" Back To Theaters With $5 Tickets
- We Need More Than Awareness
- FSU Trailblazer: Mia Hartley
- The Rest Cure: A Look Back on Women's Treatment of Mental Health
- Joss Whedon Wants You To Vote
MOST POPULAR OHIO STATE NEWS
BROWSE OTHER COLLEGES
- By CollegeAntioch UniversityAshland UniversityBaldwin-Wallace CollegeBluffton UniversityBowling Green State UniversityCapital UniversityCase Western Reserve UniversityCedarville UniversityCentral State UniversityCincinnati Christian UniversityCincinnati State Technical and Community CollegeClark State Community CollegeCleveland State UniversityCollege of Mount St. JosephColumbus College of Art & DesignColumbus State Community CollegeCuyahoga Community CollegeCuyahoga Community College-WestshoreDenison UniversityDeVry ColumbusEastern Gateway Community CollegeEdison Community CollegeFranciscan University of SteubenvilleFranklin UniversityHeidelberg CollegeHiram CollegeHocking CollegeJohn Carroll UniversityKent State UniversityKent State University SalemKenyon CollegeLakeland Community CollegeLorain County Community CollegeLourdes CollegeMalone UniversityMarietta CollegeMarion Technical College Miami University - OxfordMiami University HamiltonMiami University MiddletownMount Union CollegeMount Vernon Nazarene UniversityMuskingum CollegeNorth Central State CollegeNortheastern Ohio Universities College of Medicine and PharmacyNorthwest State Community CollegeNotre Dame CollegeOberlin CollegeOhio Dominican UniversityOhio Northern UniversityOhio StateOhio State University at LimaOhio State University at MansfieldOhio State University at MarionOhio State University-Newark CampusOhio UniversityOhio University-ChillicotheOhio University-LancasterOhio University-SouthernOhio University-ZanesvilleOhio Wesleyan UniversityOtterbein CollegeOwens Community CollegeRhodes State CollegeShawnee State UniversitySinclair Community CollegeSouthern State Community CollegeTerra State Community College The College of WoosterThe University of FindlayTiffin UniversityUnion Institute & UniversityUniversity of AkronUniversity of CincinnatiUniversity of Cincinnati-Raymond Walters CollegeUniversity of DaytonUniversity of Northwestern OhioUniversity of Rio GrandeUniversity of ToledoUniversity of Toledo Health Science CampusUrbana UniversityUrsuline CollegeWalsh UniversityWashington State Community CollegeWilmington CollegeWittenberg UniversityWright State UniversityXavier UniversityYoungstown State UniversityZane State College
- By State
- By City